• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Presti's Bakery

Presti's Bakery, a charming spot in Little Italy, OH, offers a wide array of pastries, pizza, sandwiches, and more. With a cozy atmosphere and ample seating, it's perfect for groups. Customers rave about the authentic Italian treats like tiramisu, cookies, and biscotti. The counter service adds to the bustling vibe, creating an experience to remember. Must-try items include the lemon bars, cappuccinos, and savory dishes like stromboli and pizza. Whether you're in for a quick snack or a full meal, Presti's Bakery is a must-visit destination for delectable Italian delights.

LOCATIONS

Welcome to Presti's Bakery, a charming establishment located in Little Italy, OH, that offers a delightful array of Italian pastries, sandwiches, and other savory delights. This bakery is a must-visit spot for those craving authentic Italian flavors and a cozy dining experience.

At Presti's Bakery, you can indulge in a variety of deli salads, including Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad, and Mediterranean Salad, as well as delectable main dishes like Pizza, Stromboli, and Bruschetta. Their sandwich selection, featuring options like the Italian Sub and Chicken Cutlet, is sure to satisfy any cravings.

Customers rave about the tasty treats at Presti's Bakery, with reviews mentioning favorites like the honey biscotti, original cannoli, and tiramisu. The bakery's house-made cookies and pastries are a standout, offering a mix of traditional Italian flavors and unique twists that will leave you coming back for more.

In addition to their delectable food offerings, Presti's Bakery also provides a welcoming ambiance with plenty of seating, making it the perfect place to enjoy a leisurely meal or treat yourself to a sweet snack. The staff's friendly service adds to the overall pleasant dining experience at this beloved bakery.

So, whether you're in the mood for a cozy breakfast, a satisfying lunch, or a sweet treat to end your day, Presti's Bakery is the place to be in Little Italy. Stop by and experience the flavors and hospitality that have made this bakery a local favorite!

START YOUR REVIEW OF Presti's Bakery
Dave P.
Dave P.

A great place to visit in Little Italy. Huge selection of cookies, cannoli and pastries along with savory items like pizza and stromboli. Plenty of seating for in store dining.

Dayana G.
Dayana G.

Cappuccino and pastries were very tasty. Staff was nice and location perfect after an Italian dinner.

Annie G.
Annie G.

Our experience at Presti's was excellent. We really enjoyed the honey biscotti and the original cannoli, which had orange zest in the cream. The cappuccino with soy milk was also very good. The bakery uses a ticket counter system which was useful because we could just place our order when our number was called.

Melissa J.
Melissa J.

What isn't there to love about presti's! Whether you visit in the summer, sitting street side or in the winter bundled up inside the bakery, there is never a wrong time to pull a ticket and wait your turn. The array of cookies, by the pound or just a few, will blow your mind. Everything is fresh, house made and authentic. The counter staff are knowledgeable and patient, especially when you cannot decide between gelato or a coconut bar. So when in little Italy, go to Presti's and order a lemon bar, cappuccino or a slice pizza you will never be disappointed.

TheFoodieReviewer C.
TheFoodieReviewer C.

Located in Little Italy of OH, this charming bakery has a lot to offer. From a variety of pastries, to pizza and sandwiches, and ice cream to finish off a sweet tooth, this bakery did not disappoint. Visiting the area, I had to stop at this comfy place to check it out. Plenty of seating inside and great for groups if you consolidate tables. It's a self seating restaurant and finding seats for our party of 9 was easy. They had a lot to offer whether you want a full meal or just a snack or coffee. The only thing that they can improve is the details of service. After they asked me for my order, they went back and got my order, then called me back at the "same" register to ring me up....all the same time while a new customer is at that same register trying to order and a second customer with food was also waiting to be rung up. My suggestion is ring us up after we give the order, then deliver the food at a "different"counter. This would eliminate the crowd at the one counter.

Brian R.
Brian R.

Heaven has a Presti's Hands-down the best tiramisu on the planet. Light as a cloud. Italian cookies and biscotti so scuola vecchia that you just don't see them in bakeries, an endangered species already. They do sandwiches and breads and pastas, but gli dolce are what I'd travel half way across the country to taste. Coffee is good. It's counter service and always a mad house in there. It's part of the experience!

Melanie S.
Melanie S.

One of my coworkers brought a box of Presti's pasteries in to the office last week, and mentioned that the breakfast sandwiches looked great, so, naturally, we went for a visit after Saturday yoga. I had already sampled the pecan roll from the box at work, and it was very good - not too sweet, plenty of pecans. On Saturday morning, the place was hopping. You have to take a ticket like at a deli counter. There are 3 menus and a deli case to peruse while you're waiting (coffee, pastries, and gelato), all lined up across the wall, but not together, so you'll have to move around to see all of the options. I ordered a vanilla latte and one of the egg and cheese sandwiches. As I was paying, one of the staff was unloading the sfogiatelle into the bakery case, so I got one of those too. The coffee was super hot and on the sweet side, but it hit the spot. The sandwich was just OK - the croissant was good, but it since it was assembled in the case and heated in a press/grill, it was a little dry and needed something else. The pastry was great - the phyllo cracks when you bit it, an absurd amount of powdered sugar that gets everywhere, and a lemony creamy filling. We were able to snag a table by the window pretty quickly. We were impressed by the price of our breakfast - it was under $20 each for the pastry, sandwich, and coffee. For sure a fun place to visit again!